The cosmological argument is less a particular argument than an argument type. A defense of the kalam cosmological argument and the btheory of time curtis j. Dec 28, 2011 cosmological concept which is complete from logical point of view initial composition of boundless space from the point of view of element. Oct 20, 2017 objections so bad i couldnt have made them up worst objections to kalam cosmological argument duration.
Craig provides a broad assessment of the argument in lieu of recent developments in philosophy, mathematics, science and theology. Thus, the second premiss is concerned with change, and it asserts that if the series or sequence. It means i suspend judgment on the kalam cosmological argument until there is something like a consensus among cosmologists about the beginning of the universe. Explaining the kalam cosmological argument, craig writes. Kalam cosmological argument bibliography philpapers. Cosmological argument stanford encyclopedia of philosophy. The cosmological argument has taken many forms, with variations arguing from different premises, but for our purposes, we will examine a version called the kalam cosmological argument, developed by contemporary philosopher and theologian william lane craig.
What follows is a short presentation of the kalam cosmological argument for the existence of. Mackies analysis of the kalam cosmological argument. Pdf kalam cosmological argument and the modern science. In closing, i find it strange for an atheist to appeal to aristotelian metaphysics to undermine the kalam cosmological argument. Sep 09, 2012 what we call today the kalam cosmological argument, was first made by aristotle and then by islamic scholars in the 9th century. Introduction one of the most popular arguments theists use to demonstrate gods existence is the cosmological argument. Cosmological argument page 2 of 5 the kalem is a version of the cosmological argument coming from the islamic tradition. The more controversial premise in the argument is premise 2, that the universe began to exist. Cliffe knechtle is belief in the christian god rational. May 07, 2014 in closing, i find it strange for an atheist to appeal to aristotelian metaphysics to undermine the kalam cosmological argument. He argues that if the first two premises are true, then premise three. A critical analysis of the kalam cosmological argument by al. The kalam cosmological argument is an exercise in positive deist apology which aims to demonstrate that the existence of god can be inferred to be highly probable.
My goal is to show that this second theistic part is unsound. Firstly, cohen argues that, if the argument against the possibility of an actual infinite, which is used to support the kalam cosmological argument, is sound, then a predetermined endless future must also be impossible. The kalam cosmological argument is, essentially, the argument from first cause dressed up in new clothes. Cosmos refers to the universe as an ordered system from kosmos, greek. In a critique of craigs book the kalam cosmological argument, michael martin states. The cosmological argument or first cause argument is a philosophical argument for the existence of god which explains that everything has a cause, that there must have been a first cause, and that this first cause was itself uncaused. Unfortunately, i believe that they also both partake of the same error, which. Stop using the kalam cosmological argument youtube. The kalam cosmological argument by william lane craig and.
That is an unproven assumption that is disproved by the physics phenomenon known as spontaneous pair production an example of things happening without cause, but. In this chapter i defend three arguments in support of this premise, namely, the argument based on. The kalam cosmological argument is a modern formulation of the cosmological argument for the existence of god. May 23, 2015 the original kalam cosmological argument was developed by islamic scholars in medieval times based on the aristotelian prime mover idea. The leibnizian cosmological argument appearedtoblogly. Feb 28, 2015 this argument against the existence of god fails to fully understand the kalam cosmological argument. How to debunk the kalam cosmological argument debating. What follows is a short presentation of the kalam cosmological argument for the existence of god. It was popularized by william lane craig in his book, the kalam cosmological argument 1979 the arguments key underpinning idea is the metaphysical impossibility of actual infinities and.
There is a reason x for thinking that there is a first cause of things of type t. Topics kalam collection opensource language english. There are many arguments that can he presented to prove the existence of god. The qurans argument for gods existence hamza andreas. But as scholars have debated its terms and premises over the years, theyve quickly given rise to much larger questions about cosmology, physics, mathematics, and the. William lane craig has given a similar argument which follows the same logical format which is, 1 all men are mortal, 2 socrates is. A bayesian formulation of the kalam cosmological argument. Kalam cosmological argument, the macmillan press ltd, 1979, p. Essay the kalam cosmological argument by theodore schick.
Craig provides a broad assessment of the argument in lieu of recent developments in philosophy, mathematics, science and. Lets examine both philosophical arguments and scientific evidence in support of premise 2. It is sufficient to declare existence of lord and almighty in other element. The second part aims to establish that this cause is god or gods act of creation. In professor mackie and the kalam cosmological argument religious studies, xx 1984, 36775, professor william lane craig undertakes to demonstrate that j. Although the argument is fundamentally islamic, and. The cosmological argument is said to be sound by those who support it. The most basic logical argument is the deductive syllogism.
At most, this kalam argument shows that some personal agent or agents created the universe. It uses a general pattern of argumentation logos that makes an inference from particular alleged facts about the universe cosmos to the existence of a unique being, generally identified with or referred to as god. Over the years many different versions of it have been presented. A key premise of the kalam cosmological argument is that the universe came into existence. Most people are aware that there is no single cosmological argument, but rather that the term refers to a type of argument.
The most simple criticism of the kalam cosmological argument. The kalam argument popular writings reasonable faith. So i think that the first premise of the kalam cosmological argument is surely true. William lane craig, the kalam cosmological argument, the macmillan press ltd, 1979, p. Everything that has a beginning of its existence has a cause of its existence.
Kalam cosmological argument james still the clocks were functioning, thus someone must have set them in motion, even if their winding had been designed to last a long time. But, to nonsupporters, it comes with numerous weaknesses and may therefore be invalid. In defending the faith, however, it is useful to present a way of proving the existence of god that begins from the fact of the existence of the world. A bayesian formulation of the kalam cosmological argument calum miller st hughs college, university of oxford, oxfordshire, ox2 6le, uk email. The cosmological argument has several strengths that have attracted many supporters. The kalam cosmological argument is one of the variants of the argument which has been especially useful in. I the other philosophical argument o ered in defense of premise 2 is that there cannot be an actual in nite in the world, merely a potential in nite. A defense of the kalam cosmological argument and the b. These questions have been intelligently addressed in a paper entitled the kalam cosmological argument and the problem of divine creative agency and purpose.
The kalam cosmological argument by william lane craig and james sinclair. X is b in an syllogism of this type, if the premises are true then the conclusion must be true. Philosophical arguments for the finitude of the past. A cosmological argument, in natural theology and natural philosophy not cosmology, is an argument in which the existence of god is inferred from alleged facts concerning causation, explanation, change, motion, contingency, dependency, or finitude with respect to the universe or some totality of objects. The sources used in this presentation are documented according to current modern language association standards. Of all the apologia that i encountered, my own personal opinion is that the two arguments which make the best case are the argument from first cause and the argument from design. Consult the cited works of craig for a more thorough statement and defense of the argument. Of the many ongoing debates to answer this question, william craig examines one of the most controversial proofs for the existence of god. The kalam cosmological argument by theodore schick, he states that there is scientific proof for explaining the creation of the universe, but this proof also provides evidence of what others believe shows the existence of god, who to them, is the one who created the big bang that then created the universe. The cosmological argument is probably the most popular of the theological existence proofs. The fact that the universe exists means that somebody must have created it in the first place, and this somebody is most likely god. Pdf craig, mackie, and the kalam cosmological argument. On the kalam cosmological argument common sense atheism. Likewise, in the cosmological argument, the clause begins to exist should not mean the same thing when applied to the universe that it means when applied to individual things within the universe.
Pdf huduth argument in contemporary western philosophy known as kalam cosmological argument is an argument for the existence of. Cosmological argument kalam one approach in proving what the bible says about god is through the cosmological argument. It was popularized by william lane craig in his book, the kalam cosmological argument 1979. To arrive at this conclusion, the argument employs facts concerning causation, cosmology, and contingency, as related to the beginning or coming into being of the universe. Yishai cohen raises three related objections to the kalam cosmological argument. An outspoken defender of the argument is william lane craig, who first defended it in his book the kalam cosmological argument in 1979. Metcalfe abstract william lane craig is the most recognizable contemporary defender of the kalam cosmological argument.
Objections so bad i couldnt have made them up worst objections to kalam cosmological argument duration. An argument is the presentation of reasons and evidence in a logical format that leads to a conclusion. In defending the faith, however, it is useful to present a way of proving the existence of god that. Not could be true, might be true, true if you like it, or true for. Is the kalam cosmological argument a sound proof for god. The original kalam cosmological argument was developed by islamic scholars in medieval times based on the aristotelian prime mover idea. The kalam cosmological argument sometimes capitalized as kalam cosmological argument. This paper is concerned with the kalam cosmological argument, which aims to demonstrate that the universe was created ex nihilo by a personal creator. William lane craig has refined it to make it the cornerstone of his argument for the existence of the god of christianity. The flaw in that argument is the idea that everything that begins to exist had a cause. As shandon guthrie explains, the kalam cosmological argument is the product of a history of refined evidence utilizing astronomy and astrophysics to empirically demonstrate that a cause for the universe is necessary if we are to make sense of its existence italics added. The first part aims to establish that there is a cause of the universe. It should be obvious that craigs conclusion that a single personal agent created the universe is a non sequitur.
Introduction a cosmological argument takes some cosmic feature of the universe such as the existence of contingent things or the fact of motion that calls out for an explanation and argues that this feature is to be explained in terms of the activity of a first cause, which first. Kalam cosmological argument william lane craig palgrave. It is traditionally known as an argument from universal causation, an argument from first. It is suffucient to declare existence of two elements, simple and complex, possesing closed systemic appearance in order to imagine different homogenous and completed one. As shandon guthrie explains, the kalam cosmological argument is the product of a history of refined evidence utilizing astronomy and astrophysics to empirically demonstrate that a cause for the universe is necessary if we. The argument, in its simplest form, is that i whatever begins to. The cosmological argument for the existence of god by w. Even if we grant, for the sake of argument, that this allows him to avoid the conclusion of the kca, he has just given credence to different arguments for gods existence e. How to debunk the kalam cosmological argument debating religion. What we call today the kalam cosmological argument, was first made by aristotle and then by islamic scholars in the 9th century. In this essay, we have seen that the quran provides an intuitive and powerful argument for gods existence. Pdf we present a formal analysis of the revised version of the kalam cosmo logical argument advocated by w.
627 600 690 59 311 1086 1308 810 471 1472 745 359 473 1137 1105 1023 1121 1374 1056 601 1162 703 1034 1352 1478 12 659 222 1264 898 31 1202